The episode starts with one of the Blues on a cliff sitting in a chair reading a comic book. Then, Foreman Pig is seen on a tall rock, spying on the Blue. He then sees the eggs, followed up by consulting his blueprint of a trap to catch the Blues. He speeds down the rock and begins constructs it. Alerted by the noise made by the construction, the Blue calls out his brothers who then see Foreman Pig's constructing and disguising the trap. The other Blues become angry at Foreman but when the first Blue whispers his plan to them, they agree and hide in the bushes.
Soon, the trap was complete. Foreman Pig uses a trail of birdseed to lure the Blue reading the comic, then hides. The Blue spots the seed and eats the trail. At the end of the trail the Blue is under the trap. Foreman pushes a button and traps him, but leaves the remote behind. Then, another of the Blues comes and frees the trapped Blue, who is unharmed. Foreman Pig then comes to steal the eggs but sees the supposedly trapped Blue sitting in his deck chair. Confused, Foreman Pig goes back to check his trap to find it empty.
Improving on the trap, Foreman Pig makes sure that the trapped Blue will not be freed again. Repeating the procedure, he goes back to the eggs to find the trapped Blue waiting for him. Seeing that the trapped failed again, he whines so loudly that it can be heard all over the island.
Foreman Pig uses a metal safe for his trap and repeats the trapping process. This time when he returns to the eggs, the Blue is not in the chair. Foreman proceeds to steal the eggs. Suddenly, the Blues pop out from behind the eggs, which are actually cardboard cutouts. The middle Blue pushes a button and a trap falls on Foreman. The Blues throw him back to Pig City via slingshot. He hits the castle and it collapses. The episode ends with the Blues cheering.